On Friday, I went through my entire email inbox and cleared out 14,000 emails over the past two years, either filing or deleting all of them and I have reduced my inbox to now only 44 emails. I wanted to do that because I was behind on some correspondence and I needed to know who I needed to respond to and who I didn’t, but it’s not as many people as I thought. I was invited to appear on a podcast about my typing and I don’t know whether I’m going to do it or not. That part of my life does feel over. I also discovered that apparently my typing book was unpublished on Draft2Digital, where I had my ebook published for people who didn’t want to buy it on Amazon. I originally published it on Smashwords, which I guess became Draft2Digital at some point, and apparently they added an annual fee and I had a negative balance with them and I didn’t even notice because it got drowned out by hundreds of other emails. I don’t really care since the book was published five years ago and now my book sales have almost entirely dried up and I think at most ten people bought it from there anyway.
Kyle Kirkwood was next alphabetically so I decided to throw him here although obviously there’s no chance I’m not listing him. I decided to throw Tyler Reddick in as well because his case is very much like Kirkwood’s where even if he’s not a lock yet, he certainly will be by the time I’m done. Since I’ve been doing columns of five, I had two extra drivers I needed to take care of, and now that I’ve quickly gone over those guys, I can simply do all the remaining 30 groups of five to finish this.
Reds Kagle (14)
Summary: Another obscure minor-league NASCAR driver with 147 verified wins on The Third Turn, with 45 Modified and 76 Late Model Sportsman wins.
Case for: It’s too many wins to not give the slightest consideration to, but that’s really about it. The fact that he won a lot in both the Modified tour and Late Model Sportsman tour probably gives him a slight edge over the drivers who won an equivalent number of races in one tour alone.
Case against: As you may recall, there have been a lot of obscure grassroots NASCAR drivers on here, and winning 100+ races in the pre-1985 Modified tour and pre-1982 proto-O’Reilly Series is not exactly rare. Tons of obscure drivers have done this and I don’t think Kagle stands out from enough of the pack to list him. He doesn’t have any particularly strong points finishes either: his best Modified points finish is 7th and his best Late Model Sportsman finish is 15th. I know that he probably cherry-picked races and didn’t enter as many as the top championship contenders, but still… He neither led a lap nor finished better than fourth in his 25 Cup Series starts, and that fourth-place finish came against a 16-car field.
Verdict: Drop. Too similar to too many other drivers.
Iggy Katona (16)
Summary: A more interesting stock car driver, Katona held the records for both the most ARCA wins (79) and titles (6) until Frank Kimmel broke both with 10 and 80, respectively. Nobody really took Kimmel that seriously as a major talent and I’m certainly not considering him here (his rating in my stock car model is a miserable -.314, albeit based on a pretty small sample size), which has led most people to conclude that Katona is the ARCA goat. While the series was never seriously competitive with NASCAR (unlike the AAA/USAC Stock Car tour), he certainly competed there when it was significantly more relevant than it became when it was essentially just a support series for NASCAR during NASCAR’s entire modern era.
Case for: The ‘60s were certainly the decade when ARCA peaked in driver quality. From 1955-1971, only six drivers won championships, but with the odd exception of Harold Smith in 1961, they were all really solid and won bunches of titles consecutively. Katona won three in a row from 1955-1957, then Nelson Stacy won three in a row from 1958-1960, then after Smith’s title, Katona won the 1962 title, Jack Bowsher won three in a row from 1963-1965, then Katona (1966-1967), Benny Parsons (1968-1969), and Ramo Stott (1970-1971) had a pair of titles each. Many of these drivers except for Parsons are obscure now, but Bowsher ranks third with 53 wins, Stacy ranks fourth with 43, and Stott ranks seventh with 27. They were all really strong in other series, as Bowsher also won 21 USAC Stock Car races at a time when that series had kinda comparable competition to the Cup Series short track races, Stott won 96 IMCA races, a USAC Stock Car title and 12 races there when the series was less competitive, and Stacy won 4 Cup races in 45 starts against very strong fields, including both the Southern 500 and World 600 (I’ll get to him later). If Katona was still a prolific winner against those guys who were all successful in other series, it seems like he should be on the list.
Case against: Although I think most people consider Katona the ARCA goat, I definitely don’t. It’s clearly Bowsher. Bowsher only competed full-time in ARCA three seasons, won the title all three years, and had three of the four winningest seasons in series history in those years (the other is actually the aforementioned Smith with 14). Katona did win 11 races in his 1966 and 1967 title seasons (more than Kimmel ever did), but he was a career compiler in one series and I think some of his contemporary champions hit higher peaks. The best way to get a grip on this I suppose is to compare win counts and head-to-heads against Bowsher, Parsons, Stacy, and Stott. Now, I have Bowsher, Parsons, and Stott as locks and Stacy also in the bubble tier.
[Beep, beep, boop, boop. Manually counting all their head-to-head finishing and winning records. I decided to do just who finished ahead regardless of whether they DNFed or not unlike how I did it in my model. And there are lots of races with incomplete finishing results, so they probably all had more starts against each other than this, but still…]
Okay, Bowsher beat Katona 69-40 in finishes and 39-15 in wins. Stacy beat Katona 56-47 in finishes and 25-6 in wins. Parsons beat Katona 36-35 in finishes and 15-8 in wins, but if you throw out Parsons’s 1965 season before he’d really arrived, that improves to 33-24 and 15-5. Stott beat Katona 45-26 in finishes and 23-7 in wins. They all kicked his ass. It was not even close. And maybe these comparisons strengthen Stacy’s ARCA goat case tbh. So, Katona won some titles, Stacy overtook him until he defected to NASCAR, then Katona dominated for a while until Bowsher overtook him until he defected to USAC, then Katona dominated again for a while until Parsons overtook him until he defected to USAC, and then Stott dominated after Parsons left before he defected to USAC also. Okay, that puts me in a very different position than I thought I’d be.
Verdict: Drop. I thought by reputation Katona would deserve it, but he was one of stock car racing’s biggest career compilers and he actually was a lot more like Kimmel than anyone realized. He was no match for the four truly great drivers in the series, and he looks more like the Justin Allgaier of the ‘60s. And I will not be listing Allgaier, so I guess I shouldn’t list Katona either. The truly devastating comparison is Stacy, who I also had on the bubble (unlike the other three who I already had as locks). If he wasn’t even close to Stacy, the one of these drivers I already had on the bubble who had Cup success but wasn’t exactly a superstar or anything, I kind of wonder whether Katona would’ve even won in the Cup Series at all if he’d tried. This definitely convinces me I should bump Stacy up though.
Ralf Kelleners (17)
Summary: The son of three-time European Touring Car Champion Helmut Kelleners, Ralf had an okay sports car career, but looking at it right now, I’m instantly wondering why I placed him this high. He won two relatively minor league titles (the ADAC GT Cup Division 1 in 1994 and the Porsche Carrera Cup Germany in 1996) and had 16 overall wins and 17 class wins, but like Pierre Kaffer, he didn’t seem to have that high a peak.
Case for: Kelleners was strong in the ‘90s when he won five Porsche Supercup races along with class wins at the 24 Hours of Le Mans, 24 Hours of Daytona, and Petit Le Mans in three consecutive years from 1996 to 1998.
Case against: However, I’m not particularly impressed by his 2000s. After the IMSA split, he competed in both Grand-Am and the American Le Mans Series, winning three class wins in 2002 including a second 24 Hours of Daytona, and a single ALMS class win in 2004. However, his one class win in 40 ALMS starts and three Grand-Am wins in 34 starts are hardly electrifying. Porsche Carrera Cup Germany is a series I value as it’s a top-tier minor league, but it is still a minor league and ADAC GT is probably even less significant. He has a -.115 rating in my touring car model primarily based on a mediocre DTM season. I was unable to find teammate comparisons for the 1993-1999 Porsche Supercup seasons and I do include that series in my model, so he’d look a little better if I did that, but nah.
Verdict: Drop. He had some big wins but was nowhere near a dominant force. If I’m gonna be harsh enough to say no to drivers like Julian Bailey, Klaus Graf, Pierre Kaffer, and Boris Said who had much stronger legacies and am thinking about dropping Michael Christensen and Joey Hand also, Kelleners doesn’t cut the mustard.
Todd Kelly (18)
Summary: The older brother of 2006 Supercars champion Rick Kelly, Todd actually won 19 races to Rick’s 14, mainly because he tended to have faster cars in his career before they drove for their family’s eponymous Kelly Racing, but he was nowhere near as good. Todd also earned three marquee race wins, the 2005 Bathurst 1000, 2003 Sandown 500, and 2003 Bathurst 24 Hour.
Case for: On the surface, a driver with 19 wins in a very competitive era of Supercars who also won all the major marquee races in the discipline would seem like a slam dunk. He is one of five drivers with 10+ Supercars wins who I don’t have as a lock, along with Will Brown, Fabian Coulthard, Anton de Pasquale, and Brodie Kostecki, but obviously Brown, de Pasquale, and Kostecki are still relevant so that could change (and I suspect Kostecki will be a lock soon), while Coulthard and Kelly’s careers are now set in stone. He actually only lost to five-time champion Mark Skaife 59-71 in their head-to-head, which includes his part-time rookie season in 2000, and 15-21 in wins if you exclude Skaife’s 2000 title season. I think his teammate record may be a little worse than it should be since he was typically stronger in his early seasons against 2-driver teams than he was in his many mediocre seasons later in his career when he was on a 4-driver team.
Case against: Even though Todd won more races than Rick, Rick was better, no question, and not just because he won a title. Rick’s career head-to-head record against his teammates is 800-476 to Todd’s negative 491-541. Rick’s record against Todd personally is 163-89, and he is substantially higher in my touring car model as a result also (.164 to .048). Because they both competed as part of a four-car Kelly Racing team for so long, these sample sizes of teammate comparisons are so massive that they cannot be attributed to luck. Rick was significantly better, and remember, he’s still considered to be one of the worst Supercars champions ever by a lot of people! So, where does that leave Todd? Todd also never finished better than fourth in the championship and had a relatively short run. Although he did win every year from 2000 to 2008, he never won afterward and he only won one race all of those seasons except for 2005, 2006, and 2007, when he won 5, 5, and 3 respectively. Greg Murphy beat him 9-2 in wins and 50-30 in finishes. Although Kelly sometimes outperformed Skaife, it’s clear that Skaife was past his prime and far less consistent than he used to be, but he still won more. Kelly’s Bathurst 1000 win and Sandown 500 win came with Skaife and his Bathurst 24 Hour win came with Peter Brock, Greg Murphy, and Jason Bright, who were all better drivers (although Brock certainly wasn’t in 2003). He only ranked 18th on Supercars’ list of the top 25 drivers since 2000 and I certainly don’t think I’m gonna list the guys like David Reynolds, Nick Percat, and Lee Holdsworth who are right behind him (although why were Cam Waters, Bright, and Broc Feeney behind all of them even at that point?)
Verdict: Keep. I think it’s too many wins against too strong competition and he was too close to Skaife to drop him immediately, but I’m definitely going to need to do more research into how he won all those races. I have not collected lead change data for all the 2000s races yet, but if I do and find out that Kelly was winning on pit strategy rather than speed a lot in his peak years from 2005-2007 and it was kind of a Ryan Newman/Clint Bowyer/Adrián Fernández/Marcus Ericsson thing, then I might surprisingly drop him.
Sheldon Kinser (19)
Summary: The elder brother of Steve Kinser, the goat of sprint car racing, Sheldon tends to fade into the background relative to his brother’s success, but he had a respectable career with three USAC Sprint titles in 1977, 1981, and 1982 and 37 wins in that series and 5 Silver Crown wins. Despite Steve’s success and the later successes of Mark and Kraig Kinser in the World of Outlaws, Sheldon never made a serious attempt there and only made eight WoO starts.
Case for: I have all the drivers with more USAC Sprint wins than Kinser in at least in my Near Lock category, and most of them I have in locks, although admittedly the driver right behind in wins, Jon Stanbrough with 35 is a driver I overlooked and actually haven’t considered yet, but I don’t think that case is very strong since he was kind of a career compiler who didn’t hit a strong peak. He does have more verified wins (81) than Kinser though (53) across all series, so I probably need to add him to my list of drivers to reconsider. All the drivers with three or more USAC Sprint titles are in at least my Near Lock category also with the exception of Steve Butler (who I already acknowledge I underrated) and Robbie Stanley (who it looks like I badly underrated since I only gave him 8 points). He feels like he belongs, but I think I need to recalibrate a lot of these drivers probably since I don’t have Bryan Clauson, Larry Dickson, and Tracy Hines as locks when I probably should and I probably needed to bump up Butler, Stanbrough, and Stanley at least a little also. I need to calibrate this series better than I thought I did. I know there’s a difference between winged and non-winged sprint abilities, but in 1977 (the year before Steve switched to the World of Outlaws and won its inaugural title), Sheldon beat Steve 10-3 in USAC sprint cars, although Steve beat Sheldon 6-3 after that.
Case against: I tend to rate the drivers who won in all three USAC divisions (Sprint, Midget, and Silver Crown) higher than those who only won in one and he never really attempted midgets (only two USAC starts) nor did he ever dominate the World of Outlaws like his brother or his cousin Mark did, and they both had way more wins (even Mark). His win total is pretty paltry, but still better than Stanley’s 17 (which I guess is why I underrated him so hard, but reminding myself of this, I still think Stanley probably shouldn’t be on the list). But admittedly, Kinser’s Silver Crown crossover is good.
Verdict: Keep. If Sheldon was that close to Steve immediately before the start of Steve’s WoO career, I think that probably cinches it for me. The number of wins and titles he had were already a strong case. That doesn’t mean I’m going to make him a lock or anything, but he should probably be on the list. The real question here is whether I should give more love to some of those other drivers, especially Stanbrough and Stanley.
Kyle Kirkwood (14)
Verdict: Keep. Let’s not even discuss this, shall we? He’s technically here because he had only scored 14 cumulative points through the 2025 season, but I’ve already said I’m going to give him an E for 2026, which will take him to 24 points, meaning all he has to do is have a top 200 season once after this to be a lock. He’s either equivalent to or barely worse than his ex-teammate Colton Herta, who I already had as a lock two years ago. We know he deserves it. The more interesting question is what to do with the two other stars from his rookie cohort, Christian Lundgaard and David Malukas. I think their 2026 performances put Lundgaard on the bubble and Malukas right outside it, but they’ll probably make it, too. And while we’re at it…
Tyler Reddick (19)
Verdict: Keep. Let’s just get the other similar case out of the way while we’re at it, even though he’s not alphabetically next in the sequence. A lot of people would be surprised that I didn’t have him as a lock already I guess, especially when I’ve already had Christopher Bell and William Byron as locks for a while. I kind of feel he’s more naturally talented than them, too, but I’ve had a few slight hesitations. He has always been negative in my teammate model while the other two haven’t. I just think Byron and Bell’s best seasons were better as I’ve given both of them full Es before and I’ve never given Reddick a higher grade than E-, and obviously Bell’s overall career is better when considering all his midget car performances. For most of 2026, I expected to give him a full E after he dominated in the first half, but then he tanked in the second half, so this will probably be another E-, which will only take him to 24 as well, like Kirkwood. But again, we know he deserves it. And he’ll obviously be a lock before I finish.

