Okay, this is the last group of L drivers, so I decided to use a superficially clever Smash Mouth quote here because just as in my previous entry, I’m dropping four drivers here. Do I think they’re total losers? No. In fact, I’d say this group was a little stronger than the last as I’d say these drivers are a bit closer to the bubble than yesterday’s, but I still think they are clear cuts.
I have to leave for my doctor’s appointment pretty shortly, so I’m just going to blast through a lot of stuff quickly. I received the two Greg Fielden books recapping the history of the NASCAR Late Model Sportsman tour so hopefully I’ll have more precise data to evaluate those drivers. I completed my WEC table very early this morning, so I think I’m going to have a post reviewing the WEC season tomorrow before I go through all the many, many M drivers (which will take the entirety of next week). I scheduled an interview with a podcaster who wants to talk to me about my typing for Black Friday and there was also somebody who might be interested in sending me a prototype keyboard for a paid evaluation. Finally, my cell phone stopped working this morning for no apparent reason and I had to call TracFone (yep, I still have a flip phone) about six times to finally get through to them so they could help me fix it, but they did and that’s fine.
Herbert Linge (19)
Summary: A pioneering Porsche driver, Linge earned two major overall wins, one in the prestigious Tour de Corse rally (Porsche’s first win in the event) in 1960 and another in 1968’s grueling 84-hour Marathon de la Route at the Nürburgring, which he won with Dieter Glemser and Willi Kauhsen. However, the vast majority of Linge’s wins were class wins in the World Sportscar Championship.
Case for: I have Linge listed for 19 WSC class wins from 1954 to 1969, although that is murky because sometimes different sources list certain teams as competing in different classes. World Sports Racing Prototypes, which is the site I trust most (and it’s annoying that the site doesn’t seem to work except through the Internet Archive anymore) lists him with four 24 Hours of Le Mans class wins in 1960, 1961, 1965, and 1967, but Wikipedia gives him another in 1963 while WSRP does not and I don’t know which is right, but I usually prefer WSRP’s data. Nearly all of Linge’s class wins came in major events, including three Targa Florios, two Mille Miglias, a 24 Hours of Daytona and also a win in its forerunner, the 2000 Kilometers of Daytona, and the Tour de France Automobile. He also had class wins in the European Touring Car Championship and the British Saloon Car Championship and a class win in the 12 Hours of Nürburgring. That’s a lot of class wins over an extremely long time, and he really was partially responsible for putting Porsche on the map, not only for the Tour de Corse win, but also for his Le Mans successes, where he drove for the highest-finishing Porsche team overall three times (1960, 1963, 1965). He won with a lot of different co-drivers and all his Le Mans class wins came with a different co-driver.
Case against: The one nagging question I have is whether he finished close enough to the overall lead and faced enough competition in his WSC class wins. Going through all his wins, I find:
6th an hour behind with 27 entries and 12 finishers
14th an hour, 43 minutes behind with 15 entries and 9 finishers
10th 26 laps down with 1 finisher
6th 37 minutes behind with 16 starters and 8 finishers
10th 45 laps down with 4 starters and 2 finishers
8th 1 lap down with 8 starters and 3 finishers
10th 49 laps down with 4 starters and 2 finishers
6th 43 minutes behind with 6 starters and 4 finishers
6th 3 laps down with 7 starters and 5 finishers
7th 11 laps down with 4 starters and 4 finishers
3rd 30 minutes behind with 5 starters and 3 finishers
4th 1 lap down with 10 starters and 6 finishers
6th 16 laps down with 15 starters and 8 finishers
3rd with 9 starters and 4 finishers
8th 12 laps down with 7 starters and 5 finishers
4th 12 laps down with 5 starters and 2 finishers
6th 55 laps down with 4 starters and 3 finishers
14th 80 laps down with 4 starters and 1 finisher
16th 28 laps down with 4 starters and 4 finishers
I’ve got to say I don’t love this. Furthermore, even though I definitely think he helped put Porsche on the map, he wasn’t the first class winner at Le Mans (that was Auguste Veuillet and Edmond Mouche in 1951) nor was he the first overall winner (that was his onetime co-driver Hans Herrmann in 1970 with Richard Attwood). There were other Porsche drivers who won some of the WSC races he won in class, but obviously they were in faster classes. ewrc-results.com also claims that Paul Ernst Strähle was the lead driver and Linge was actually the navigator in the Tour de Corse win, and I do not typically credit navigator wins in rallies for this list, although admittedly most other sources list Linge as the lead driver, so I’m not sure which is correct.
Verdict: Keep. I think I’m still going to keep him for now since he earned a lot of class wins and almost all of them came in marquee races, but I’ve got to say at this point I’m somewhat less convinced since those classes mostly did not have great competition and he was seldom even close to the overall lead. But I could see myself changing my mind.
Mike Little (14)
Summary: Early NASCAR Late Model Sportsman driver who finished third in points all three years that Mike Klapak won the title. Before he pivoted to NASCAR, he won 12 races in the AAA Michigan/Ohio Midget series and 2 Eastern Big Car wins.
Case for: Little actually has more verified wins than his fellow Mike in all three seasons Klapak won the title, as Little had 30, 21, and 10 wins in 1950-1952 respectively while Klapak had 12, 20, and 8, but who knows what the complete win counts are since I suspect many tracks weren’t reporting results then? What Little has over Klapak in addition to wins is that he won in more different types of cars than Klapak did. Although Klapak has more listed wins (70) on The Third Turn than Little (62), Little would have more if you counted his AAA Sprint and Midget wins as well, which The Third Turn doesn’t have on its site.
Case against: On the other hand, what Klapak has that Little doesn’t is at least a few major league wins in the USAC Stock Car Series. Late Model Sportsman was not a major league and he wasn’t on that list of winningest drivers I provided in the Klapak entry. Furthermore, a bunch of drivers had a bunch of wins in this era, most of whom I will not be listing. Pappy Hough, who I earlier rejected, finished 2nd in 1950 with 23 wins (nearly twice as many as Klapak but not as many as Little). Then in 1951 and 1952, Dick Linder (who won 3 Cup Series races in 1950) finished second in points both years and won 32 and 20 races in 1951 and 1952, giving him at least 10 more verified wins both seasons, and despite his Cup wins I don’t think I’m listing him either. I don’t think the Michigan/Ohio Midget series was the most prestigious midget series either. And he won no titles in any discipline.
Verdict: Drop. While he was an early standout on the Late Model Sportsman tour, I’ve already rejected all the similar drivers from his era that he was competing against. Ergo, I should probably reject him too.
Vitantonio Liuzzi (14)
Summary: A once much-vaunted prospect who won the Karting World Championship in 2001 and F1’s then-top feeder series Formula 3000 in 2004 with a record seven wins, he never ended up doing very much in F1, but his model numbers are solid, he won three Speedcar Series races, five International Superstars Series races, and one GT Asia win after his F1 career ended.
Case for: In the entire history of F1’s top feeder series (whether it was called Formula 2, Formula 3000, or GP2), only one champion ever has won more races in a season than Liuzzi: Bruno Giacomelli’s eight in 1978. Liuzzi even won more races than the next two champions Nico Rosberg and Lewis Hamilton (who each only won five even though Liuzzi made only ten starts while Rosberg made 23 and Hamilton made 21). He finished third in the inaugural 2008-09 Speedcar Series against a field that included Gianni Morbidelli, Johnny Herbert, Heinz-Harald Frentzen, and Jean Alesi and part-timer Jacques Villeneuve tied Alesi with the most wins with three. He is above average in both my open wheel (.021) and touring car models (.161). He scored the first point for Red Bull’s junior operation Toro Rosso.
Case against: His F1 career is quite undistinguished, as he only scored four points for Toro Rosso in 2006 and 2007 before Sebastian Vettel became the then-youngest winner the next year at the Italian Grand Prix. I thought he absolutely demolished Scott Speed, but I looked it up and that wasn’t the case at all. In 2006, Speed had a better overtake record (18-25) and speed (har) percentile (25.64) than Liuzzi’s 11-27 and 25.29 respectively. Liuzzi was substantially better in 2007 before Speed was fired, but even that year Speed had a better average running position (14.07 to 14.64). Although Liuzzi beat Speed 18-10 in qualifying, he only beat him 12-11 in finishes and they tied 5-5 in shared finishes. While I don’t think Speed was as bad an F1 driver as people remember, he wasn’t good either, so it’s no wonder both of them were fired. Then at Force India, Adrian Sutil absolutely annihilated Liuzzi in qualifying 20-4 and beat him 13-10 finishes and 6-5 in shared finishes, and I’m not even sure Sutil is list-worthy either but I kind of doubt it (I actually haven’t evaluated him yet, but I should). Yes, he was competitive against Herbert, Alesi, Frentzen, and Villeneuve in 2008-2009, but that is when all of them were far, far from their peaks in the ‘90s. The touring car rating is good, but his touring car career wasn’t very long, he didn’t win a title, and the Italian-based Superstars Series is not exactly one of the most prestigious touring car championships anyway. So, he won a lot of minor league races. I don’t have Giacomelli on the list either.
Verdict: Drop. This is mostly a case of unrealized potential. At this point, I’d rather list his fellow Karting World Champion Lake Speed, but I don’t think he quite cuts the mustard either.
Alberto Logulo (14)
Summary: Logulo won eight races in Argentina’s Turismo Carretera championship in the ‘50s. Although his best points finish was a mere third in 1953, he did earn four more top five points finishes in 1954, 1956, 1957, and 1958, before having his peak winning season in 1959 when he won three times and finished 7th in points.
Case for: Normally, I’d reject a Turismo Carretera record like this since I’ve even rejected champions, but the ‘40s and ‘50s were definitely when the series was at its peak in relevance as Juan Manuel Fangio had competed there in the ‘40s, where he was one of the standout drivers but actually nowhere near as dominant in his domestic Argentina races as he was in his F1 dynasty run later. Oscar Gálvez ran typically just as well as Fangio and even won the last two Turismo Carretera titles over Fangio in 1947 and 1948 before he left, but Oscar had been eclipsed by his younger brother Juan starting in 1949. Both Gálvez brothers were still around in the ‘50s and together they combined to win all but one title from 1947-1961. If both these drivers were arguably near-World Champion caliber, maybe you can argue more middling drivers from this series in this era are list-worthy.
Case against: I guess this comes down to whether I think Logulo’s performance was close enough to the Gálvez brothers to be worthy of consideration. Logulo’s 8 wins came from 1952-1959. Over that timespan, Juan won five titles and 35 wins. Oscar won two titles and 25 wins. He never beat either of them in the championship and he only beat them in wins once in 1959 when he won thrice and they both won twice. As great as the Gálvez brothers were, it would be ludicrous to argue they were comparable to Fangio even though they were as good as him domestically. I would argue Fangio peaked in F1 in the ‘50s while his Turismo Carretera career is an odd footnote in the same vein as Tony Stewart’s early IRL career. If I’m going to even reject champions from this series in later periods, I don’t think I can justify this.
Verdict: Drop. Logulo is probably a closer cut than you might think since he came closer to the Gálvezes than most others and Oscar had previously matched Fangio for the most part, but this is still a niche racing category, and in an era when those two drivers combined to win 14 of 15 championships, can I really justify listing anyone else?
Richard Lyons (17)
Summary: Lyons became one of only six drivers to win both of Japan’s major league championships (Super Formula, which was then Formula Nippon, and Super GT, which was then Japanese GT500) in the same season in 2004 along with Pedro de la Rosa in 1997, Satoshi Motoyama in 2003, Naoki Yamamoto in 2018 and 2020, Ritomo Miyata in 2023, and Sho Tsuboi in 2024.
Case for: In addition to accomplishing this rare single-season feat, he had some longevity by winning four Formula Nippon races from 2003-2005 and eight Japanese GT/Super GT races from 2002-2009 in addition to a non-points win in 2010, a class win in the minor GT300 class in 2016, an Asian Le Mans class win, an International GT Open class win, and most notably a shared Supercars win at Surfers Paradise in 2011 with Mark Winterbottom. Lyons’s open wheel rating of .068 is solid but not unimpeachable (like he’s admittedly right behind Jacky Ickx and right in front of Damon Hill and Alan Jones, but on the other hand he’s also right behind Santino Ferrucci and right ahead of Roberto Merhi, for context).
Case against: I’m getting real Michael Krumm vibes off him. While Lyons was substantially better than Krumm in my open wheel model (beating him .068 to -.090), Krumm was substantially better in my touring car model by an even greater margin (.137 to -.154). At least Lyons had more solo wins by himself, so he’s a little better, but how strong was his peak period? Like Krumm, his Japanese GT title was shared with a vastly superior driver in Motoyama (who won four Formula Nippon titles and three Japanese/Super GT titles). Lyons’s Formula Nippon period is very weird in that during the period when Lyons won four Formula Nippon races from 2003-2005, Yuji Ide also won three races, and he’s oft-cited as the worst F1 driver of all time! I don’t know what to make about Lyons’s 2005 season, where he somehow finished behind Ide yet ahead of future World Endurance Championship legends André Lotterer and Benoît Tréluyer, as well as recent Bubble Boy Takashi Kogure. But Lyons certainly doesn’t have the sports car record of Lotterer and Tréluyer. Four of his Super GT wins were with Motoyama. Admittedly, the other four weren’t but he was mostly middling without Motoyama in the series. Nine Super GT wins either overall in class out of 131 total isn’t amazing. Neither is 4 out of 56 Formula Nippon wins. The double championship is nice, but that doesn’t mean I automatically have to list him considering his Super GT title was shared with a superior driver and his Formula Nippon title came in the Ide era. While Motoyama, Yamamoto, and Tsuboi are locks for sure, I don’t think I’m going to list de la Rosa (whose 1997 was a lot more dominant than Lyons’s 2004, by the way) and I’m having increasing doubts about Miyata. I ranked Miyata third in 2023 in a euphoric mood as some partial show of autistic solidarity since he was the first diagnosed autistic driver to win a major championship, and now I am convinced that was too high. I’ve already retroactively dropped Miyata to fifth, but based on what I’m doing with these other drivers, I should probably drop Miyata to E, which would take him off the list. Miyata’s Formula 2 career hasn’t been great. Sure, he’s beating his teammate Colton Herta, but who isn’t? Sweeping both titles is not necessarily enough. That leaves the Supercars win. While it’s probably his most prestigious win, he was the guest driver for Winterbottom, who was a perennial championship contender. Lyons was pretty fast and ran third for the first half, but it was Winterbottom who took the lead and the win at the end, so Lyons doesn’t get a huge amount of credit for that.
Verdict: Drop. It’s a close call, but this feels the opposite to Buddy Lazier for me. While with Lazier the vibes were right even if the credentials were wrong, it feels like the reverse here. Lyons has the stronger credentials on paper, but if you dig deeper, his career is less impressive than you think, and I think the fact that he was only barely better than Ide when they were in Formula Nippon together is what swings it for me. If he’d had a truly dominant sports car career like Lotterer or Tréluyer did, that would be another story, but his sports car career wasn’t that dominant.

