There are many, many M drivers to go through and they will take all week. I probably talked too much about some of them because I do admittedly think it is interesting to discuss why Dave Marcis isn’t deserving and why Darren Manning might be, although I ultimately rejected both.
At the doctor’s office on Friday, I started reading the first Greg Fielden Late Model Sportsman history book I just bought. Unfortunately, the books aren’t comprehensive. What I wanted was just a list of races and winners, or even just how many wins each driver had per season so I can understand those drivers’ legacies better. Instead, those books are basically just a sampler of about 30-50 of the more prestigious races each season, while he basically ignores the minor races because there were admittedly thousands of races per season, he says. For the races he does include, he does offer recaps and crude box scores and sometimes they have lap leader data in them, so I don’t regret buying them, but they were not exactly what I had in mind either. He started in 1969 because that is the year when Permatex began sponsoring the Saturday Late Model Sportsman race at Daytona the day before the Daytona 500, and apparently, that was the moment when the Late Model Sportsman and the Modified tour were officially listed as separate tours. I guess maybe those cars were actually racing together sometimes before that although I can’t prove it? I knew that drivers like Ray Hendrick and Red Farmer and Sonny Hutchins went back and forth and won a ton of races in both Modifieds and Late Model Sportsman, but apparently at some point the distinctions between the two series were harder to ascertain. This is still a big question mark that is hard to research now.
Fielden did pretty much confirm that I was right to reject Mike Klapak though. Although he did state that Klapak won 20 races in his 1950 inaugural title season (I only had 12 listed before that), he also wrote:
”Mike Klapak, of Warren, OH, who won the Championship in the first 3 years, started up to 140 races per season. He won the title simply by going to the post more times than any other competitor.
Stock Car racing was becoming a big-time sport - even in Ohio, Klapak drove in 5 races every week. Klapak won 20 events in 1950, but he lost 120.”
Okay, if he literally only won those championships because he entered more races (which doesn’t surprise me given NASCAR’s consistency-based points systems they seemingly had no interest in ever doing away with), I can see why he doesn’t really have a legacy today, and why Ray Hendrick, who has hundreds more confirmed wins does even though Hendrick never won either a Sportsman or a Modified title.
The second book from 1977-1981 covers an odd era when NASCAR introduced a championship series for the Late Model Sportsman tour whose races awarded more points, but the weekly series-type races still also awarded points to a lesser degree. Eventually, what is now the modern O’Reilly Series started in 1982 when they split the weekly series races into the NASCAR Winston Racing Series (now the Local Racing Series), but that has really cratered the legacy of drivers who peaked in the years before the Busch Series started. I guess I’ll never find out how many Late Model Sportsman races someone like Butch Lindley actually won? That’s really frustrating.
I also just got out Thomas Frank’s latest book, The Creativity Con, from the library. He’s my favorite author probably, so that should be fun.
Willy Mairesse (16)
Summary: An eclectic driver who won the 1956 Belgian Rally Championship, 5 overall World Sportscar Championship races (including the 1962 and 1966 Targa Florios) and 3 more in class (including the 1965 24 Hours of Le Mans) along with two non-championship races in Formula 1. He also won the 1960 and 1961 Tour de France Automobile rallies.
Case for: Winning in all three of these disciplines is relatively rare. His one Belgian Rally Championship win also counted towards the European Rally Championship, which was the most prestigious rallying series at the time before the World Rally Championship existed. Most of his WSC wins were overall wins and not class wins, which I like. His .066 open wheel rating is solid, but admittedly, it’s based on only eight teammate comparisons. Even though only one of his rally wins counted towards either the ERC or the Belgian Rally Championship, he actually had six rally wins.
His sports car record is arguably better than it looks since he also finished second, third, and third overall in three Le Mans starts.
Case against: I think here, I just need to look at the competition level of his non-sports car wins. The Tour de France Automobile wins were probably his biggest rallying wins, but that race did not carry the same prestige as the bicycle race bearing that same name. I’m likely to list only two drivers from his 1960 win (Olivier Gendebien and Jacques Feret) and I’m only certain to list two drivers from his 1961 win (Gendebien and Maurice Trintignant, although Hans-Joachim Walter is on the bubble and Roger de la Geneste, Henri Greder, and Paddy Hopkirk are in my near-miss category). His ERC win had Gendebien and near misses Bernard Consten, de la Geneste, and Paul Ernst Strähle. The fact that he often outperformed the lock Gendebien is good, but Gendebien actually won two Belgian Rally titles in 1954 and 1955 to Mairesse’s one and was a much better sports car driver even if he was worse in open wheel. Gendebien did have one additional overall rally win.
Mairesse’s career in points F1 races isn’t anything special. Sure, he had a third and a fourth but he was driving for Ferrari in a dominant period for them, and he didn’t make the F1metrics top 100. His Brussels Grand Prix win had a strong field that included Jim Clark, Graham Hill, John Surtees, and Stirling Moss. None of them finished, but he did beat two winners in Jo Bonnier and Innes Ireland. The Naples Grand Prix he was one of only two good drivers entered along with his teammate Lorenzo Bandini, who I previously rejected.
At Le Mans in 1961, he and Mike Parkes finished three laps behind the other Ferrari driven by Gendebien and Phil Hill. In his 1965 class win with Beurlys, they were the only finisher in their class but two other Ferraris finished ahead. In 1967, they finished third but also finished behind another Ferrari driven by Ludovico Scarfiotti and Parkes.
Verdict: Drop. He was a good driver, but this is a John Andretti “jack of all trades, master of none” to me. Crossing over between rallying, sports cars, and touring cars wasn’t that rare in the ‘60s when the distinctions between those categories were more nebulous than they later became. Ferrari entered pretty much all its drivers in sports cars and open wheel simultaneously, and I don’t think he was one of the biggest standouts in either; even in his one F1 podium he finished behind two teammates, including winner Phil Hill, who is widely regarded to be the worst F1 champion ever. He feels kind of like a lesser Lorenzo Bandini to me, and I already rejected Bandini. It’s a close miss, I think, but still a miss.
Darren Manning (14)
Summary: My vote for the most underrated driver in IndyCar history, Manning started out as a hot racing prospect by winning the Japanese Formula 3 title in 1999 along with the Macau Grand Prix and Korea Super Prix, and he even beat future World Champion Jenson Button in both those minor league “all star” events. After a lackluster stint in Formula 3000, he earned one major league win in the short-lived British NASCAR clone ASCAR (no, I am not making this up) before pivoting to CART and then the IRL, where he was actually excellent, but nobody noticed at the time because he never won.
Case for: Manning was teammates with defending British Touring Car Champion and that series’s all-time winningest driver Jason Plato in ASCAR in 2002 and although Manning finished 11th in points because he did not start all the races while Plato was 3rd, Manning was probably better since he won a race while Plato didn’t and beat him 5-3 in head-to-head finishes. After that, he switched to CART in 2003 as part of the massive rookie class that replaced the large number of drivers exiting to the IRL, F1 (Cristiano da Matta), or NASCAR (Christian Fittipaldi lol). Although Manning had nothing on Rookie of the Year and future four-time champion Sébastien Bourdais, he did beat two of the other rookies in points who went on to have accomplished careers (Ryan Over-Reayted and Tiago Monteiro) and actually led my teammate model because he swept his fellow rookie teammate, hapless ride-buyer Rodolfo Lavín, who finished 18th in points while Manning was 9th.
In 2004, Manning got what should have been his big break at Chip Ganassi Racing in the IRL when he was signed as a last-minute replacement for Tony Renna, who died in a testing crash the previous year. Ganassi signed Manning kind of half-heartedly and never seemed to have any faith in him, especially after the team suffered what remains its only winless season since 1995 that year. What got lost in the shuffle was that Manning was actually arguably outperforming Scott Dixon, the defending IRL champion and future all-time great. Manning was 8 points ahead of Dixon in 2004 entering the penultimate race in Fontana, when he suffered a season-ending back injury in qualifying, although Dixon overtook him for 10th place. That year, he had actually beaten Dixon 5-2 in the races they both finished, making him the highest-ranking driver in my teammate model for the second year in a row. Then in 2005, Ganassi abruptly fired him mid-season after deciding not to renew him in 2006. He was 14 points ahead of Dixon and 27 points ahead of his other teammate, rookie Ryan Briscoe, at the time. After Toyota significantly underfunded its IRL teams to make way for its impending NASCAR move, the Ganassi team struggled and Chip took it out on all his drivers. Briscoe was also fired before the season ended, and even Dixon came close to being fired. The team had more leeway with Dixon because he had already won a championship, and he saved his career with a win at Sonoma after both teammates were dropped.
It’s hard to imagine now, but after his disastrous 2004 and 2005, Dixon was arguably seen as a flash in the pan like 1999 IRL champion Greg Ray and people did not yet realize he was one of the best in his era. When that became apparent in hindsight, Manning looked better and better in retrospect than he ever did at the time considering he was ahead of a six-time champion and a future championship contender in Briscoe when he was fired. Manning landed a comeback with A.J. Foyt in 2007 and 2008, where he again impressed, finishing 13th and 14th in points, giving the team two of its best four points finishes between Airton Dare in 2002 and the Santino Ferrucci/David Malukas era in 2024-2025 along with Vitor Meira’s 12th-place finish in 2010 and Takuma Sato’s 14th in 2015. Recall that in the Ferrucci/Malukas era that Foyt was a Penske satellite, so that’s not really comparable. Considering Meira is widely considered the best non-winner ever and Sato is a two-time Indy 500 winner, even this puts Manning in an impressive context. He probably wouldn’t have been a champion, I think, but his chances of being a prolific race winner with some luck seem pretty good. Then in 2009, he moved to Dreyer & Reinbold, drove two races, both sides parted ways, and he was never seen again in any series. It’s a truly baffling, baffling career.
Manning beating Dixon and also leading my teammate model in 2003 still makes him, to this day, one of the highest-rated IndyCar drivers in the history of my model, ranking 33rd full-time at .286 and he’s only behind Greg Moore’s .462 amongst drivers who had multiple IndyCar seasons. That rating alone is hard to dismiss.
Case against: First off, the era when Manning emerged in the IRL was arguably one of the most sterile for competition in IndyCar history, and this is gonna come up when I discuss Meira and Tomas Scheckter too. Although the influx of the CART drivers and teams initially rejuvenated IRL competition and led to wildly competitive seasons in 2002-2004, it died down rapidly after that. The racing was still often good, but from 2005 to 2007, an absurd six-driver oligopoly of Hélio Castroneves, Dixon, Dario Franchitti, Sam Hornish, Jr., Tony Kanaan, and Dan Wheldon won an absurd 44 of 48 races, including all 17 races in the 2007 season (even late period Champ Car had more variation than that!) They also combined to win every single IRL/IndyCar championship from 2001-2011 and every Indy 500 from 2005-2013. This is beyond just “normal dominance” and something more like “full-season Cup Series regulars laying claim over the Nationwide Series dominance”. Those six drivers were so dominant that everyone else reeeeeeally starts to look second-rate. I do have Scott Sharp as a lock (almost entirely for what he did before that period), but do I really need any other drivers from this era? As long as I have those six drivers as locks, which I do, I’m good, right? And I’m not gonna say Ganassi was wrong to replace Manning with Wheldon and then eventually Franchitti, even if I think he was wrong to fire him in frigging mid-season when he was their highest-ranked driver in points. You could make a legit case that those six drivers were the only good drivers in the series and you might not be wrong.
Yes, Manning was the last driver to post a winning head-to-head record against Dixon before Álex Palou did (even Franchitti didn’t), and that is a major feather in his cap. He’s even just barely ahead of Palou in my model, who is 34th at .280, but the difference of course is that Palou has many, many wins and titles and Manning has a grand total of one (1) major league win anywhere. I do think Manning’s defeat of Dixon looked a lot more impressive then than it does now in the Palou era when we start to wonder whether Dixon was ever quite as good as we once thought.
I think the big question is whether Manning beat Dixon because Manning was good or because Dixon was bad. For this, I think we have to look at what the other Toyotas were doing. While Toyota was already a lame-duck manufacturer in the IRL as they were investing all their money into their eventual NASCAR entry in 2005, the big, big strike against Manning is that other Toyota teams were actually beating Ganassi. Penske was still doing fine. While they weren’t fast enough to be title contenders, Hornish was third in points and Castroneves was sixth in 2005 and they both won. But that’s Penske. The more damning comparison is that the two Cheever Toyotas of Patrick Carpentier and Alex Barron were actually beating all three Ganassi cars in points pretty much all season, and Carpentier was 10th and Barron was 11th last year when even Dixon after his win only managed 13th. They were also both ahead of Manning in points when he was fired. I think that actually makes the decision more obvious, since that was Carpentier’s only year in the IRL when Manning was in his second year and I already rejected Carpentier.
As for the ASCAR win, I do actually think that field was really strong since it included both the defending BTCC champion Plato and the defending British GT champion Kelvin Burt along with others like CART reject/future sports car star Nicolas Minassian and Aston Martin great Darren Turner, but it was an all-oval series and all those drivers were new to ovals, so how seriously can you take that?
Verdict: Drop. I love talking about Manning (can’t you tell?) because it’s such a weird career and I’ve rarely seen anything like it. The closest thing I can think of is Cole Whitt in NASCAR, who is erroneously remembered as a bust because he has more starts than any other driver without a top ten finish, when he was actually once the youngest USAC Midget champion and his stock car rating of .149 is actually low-key championship-caliber mainly due to how badly he thrashed Alex Bowman when they were both rookies. Obviously, I think Manning was stronger than Whitt because he lasted longer, hit a higher peak in my open wheel model, and beat Dixon in his prime. Do I think he could’ve been the seventh driver in that oligopoly if Ganassi or anyone had had a little faith in him at all? Yes. Yes. 100% yes. But can I justify listing a driver like this, as much as I like talking about him? No, I can’t. I think you have to rate on what actually happened, not what could have happened, and I think the fact that even the Cheever cars driven by two drivers who I don’t think are list-worthy were ahead of him when he was fired says he doesn’t belong.
Dave Marcis (14)
Summary: The driver with the second-most starts in NASCAR Cup Series history (883) and the most consecutive Daytona 500 starts (32), Marcis had a short run of competitiveness in the late ‘70s before randomly getting a fluke win as an owner-driver at Richmond in 1982.
Case for: Marcis won 5 NASCAR Cup Series races, which is not amazing but is credible. He finished (a very, very distant) second to Richard Petty in the 1975 season, the first year of the Latford points era. He is one of only five drivers who finished second in points who I don’t have as locks along with Clint Bowyer, Ross Chastain, James Hylton, and Cotton Owens (but the first three of those I think are safe). His 1976 season was especially strong as he tied for the third-most wins (3), the second-most poles (7), and the fifth-most laps led (893). Every driver with more than Marcis’s 2,699 laps led except for Kyle Petty, Jack Smith, and Bowyer I have as a lock on the list and literally every driver with more than his 14 poles I have as locks except for Smith (although Marcis is tied with Glen Wood, who I also have in this bubble group).
Case against: Although some of his numbers look sneakily good, I have never been able to take Marcis’s legacy all that seriously. That is mainly because I think the ‘70s were the worst decade ever for NASCAR competition, but secondarily, because I think a lot of fans misunderstand his legacy now. Ol’ Wing-Tips became an icon as the last of the independents and if all five of his wins came as an owner-driver, I’d probably do it. But… he was a factory driver in his mid-’70s heyday with the now-forgotten K&K Insurance/Nord Krauskopf team. Despite winning a championship, 43 races, and 67 poles, this team is now one of the most obscure title-winning teams in history and I’m not sure I get it. No one will ever clamor for Krauskopf to make the Hall of Fame, and even though Harry Hyde was responsible for most of those wins, it feels like the dumb voters keep rejecting him on the Hall of Fame ballot because they associate him exclusively with the Tim Richmond era and don’t realize his dominance goes back that far because again, nobody talks about this team ever. Marcis’s numbers look good in isolation, but within the context of the team, he was a step down from his predecessor Buddy Baker and a huge step down from Bobby Isaac, who had nearly all his success including his 1970 championship and his 1969 17-win/19-pole season in what was definitely recent history. Marcis did fine, but he had two very good seasons for a team that had recently had all-time great seasons. Then he led only 90 laps in a part-time Penske deal in 1977 (although admittedly, Bobby Allison had gone winless the year before), did finish fifth in points for Rod Osterlund in 1978 (and he was second entering the season finale), but he went winless that year two years before Dale Earnhardt replaced him and won the title.
After that, Marcis mostly drove for himself and he was not as impressive as you think. He won one race as an owner-driver, and it was really stupid. A couple laps after Joe Ruttman had lapped Marcis at Richmond in 1982, he crashed to let Marcis back on the lead lap. Marcis then stayed out of the pits to take the lead and it rained, giving him what remains one of the goofiest victories of the modern era. If he’d really shown dominant runs as an owner-driver, I might feel differently but he hardly ever led. And it’s not like owner-drivers couldn’t be competitive in this era! Richard Petty was technically an owner-driver. Alan Kulwicki, Geoff Bodine, Ricky Rudd, and Darrell Waltrip all had success. Bill Elliott never won but his 1997 was really solid. Even Lake Speed pummeled the field at Darlington as an owner-driver once! If Marcis had had their kind of talent, he could’ve done more (okay, maybe I’d take his career over Speed… that one’s close). I even think he pales to Hylton, who at least had five seasons he led 100+ laps as an owner-driver; Marcis had two. He accumulated a lot of laps led as a career-compiler because he stayed out of the pits very often to capture five bonus points when that was a thing, but that certainly doesn’t make him competitive by itself!
Then finally, there is my main point. It seems like a lot of old-school fans from the boomer era or earlier have some weird fixations that are hard for a modern analytical mind to understand. A lot of racing historian types seem to really venerate guys who made a lot of starts regardless of what they do in them. It seems like they view racing the way they view military service, like just putting more time in gives you a more honorable career by itself. (I would also criticize people who feel this way about military service for different reasons, but let’s not get into that now, okay?) This is how the people voting for “The Greatest 33” at the Indy 500 ended up including drivers like Cliff Bergere, Ralph Hepburn, and Chet Miller who did next to nothing, while leaving off Kenny Bräck, who had both a better overall career and better Indy career than all those guys combined. But they put in a lot of time! No, making a lot of starts is not a credential. You have to do things. Even in Marcis’s much-vaunted Daytona 500 consecutive starts streak, he never finished better than sixth.
Marcis’s career might be stronger if he had a bunch of other stock car wins in other tours like Tiny Lund or Pete Hamilton or somebody like that, but nope. 6 verified NASCAR Late Model Sportsman wins, 2 USAC Stock Car wins, 1 Cup non-points win. Not enough, I say.
Verdict: Drop. Now unlike Manning where I kind of had to talk myself out of listing him, no such talk was necessary here. I never really thought he was deserving. I’d rather list Hylton, who at least earned two more impressive wins as an owner-driver than Marcis’s one fluke win. (I’d also rather list Ruttman, but we’ll get to that later, and I haven’t made up my mind on him yet.)
Henry Martin (16)
Summary: Argentine touring car driver who posted one of the most dominant seasons in history in the TC2000 championship when he won 13 races in the championship in 1997. He never did anything like that again, but he accumulated 19 TC2000 wins, 12 Top Race wins, and 1 Turismo Carretera win from 1997-2008.
Case for: Martin’s 13 TC2000 wins in 1997 are literally the most ever in a season, and it’s possible you could argue that season by itself would be enough because I do consider the TC2000 to be a low-level major league, and Martin did beat the series’s all-time great, seven-time champion Juan María Traverso, to win that title. Although Traverso was in his late 40s and in the tail end of his career and his last title was in 1995, he was still very much relevant in the late ‘90s, as in addition to his 1995 TC2000 title, he also won four out of five Turismo Carretera titles from 1995-1999 and back-to-back Top Race titles in 1998 and 1999. He even won 10 races the same year Martin won 13, so for Martin to outduel Traverso in any context is worthy of praise. Even if a lot of the rest of his career was rather middling, he still proves his longevity beyond that year by continuing to win in one of the three Argentine series every year from 1997-2008.
Case against: This is still a niche category and one that a lot of people like to dismiss (although I do personally rate it more than most other Americans do). It would be easy to argue that 1997 was his only truly great season (especially on an international scale) while he was never more than good after that. He did finish second in TC2000 in 2000, but he never finished better than fourth in points in any other season. While a lot of drivers who competed in all three of these series won in multiple championships simultaneously, he only won races in one championship at a time and could be argued to be not quite as versatile on that basis.
Verdict: Keep. I don’t really find my case against convincing. If I do rate this scene at all, which I do, and if I do kind of view TC2000 as a major league, which I do, it would be a pretty bad snub to not include the driver who had its winningest season in history.
Markko Märtin (15)
Summary: Rally driver from the ‘90s and 2000s. After back-to-back Estonian Rally Championships in 1997 and 1998, Märtin earned five wins in the World Rally Championship and three consecutive top five points finishes in 2003-2005, peaking in his three-win 2004 when he won the prestigious Tour de Corse rally. He also won 18 overall Estonian Rally Championship wins and one European Rally Championship win. As someone whose entry into racing fandom started with ‘90s NASCAR, this guy’s name is really funny to me.
Case for: Five WRC wins is a solid number, placing him tied for 29th all-time. The period in which Märtin raced might have been one of the most competitive in series history since by the 2000s, the top drivers competed in every rally while for a lot of the ‘70s, ‘80s, and ‘90s, most of the top drivers cherry-picked rallies and didn’t enter every one, which meant the competition at each individual rally was often really shallow. Not so in the 2000s. He also won all his rallies before the withdrawal of Subaru in 2008 led to the competition plummeting in the late-period Sébastien Loeb and into the Sébastien Ogier dynasty. Märtin proved he could win against Loeb.
Case against: Märtin was a good driver, but he did pale compared to the champions, as his teammate record of 21-29 is not amazing. He did have a strong 13-4 record against drivers who did not win championships, including a 9-3 record against François Duval, the first Belgian to win a WRC event, who was his teammate at his peak. But he was 8-25 against champions in rallies both drivers finished (1-2 vs. Richard Burns, 1-8 vs. Marcus Grönholm, 2-7 vs. Colin McRae, 3-6 vs. Carlos Sainz, 1-2 vs. Petter Solberg), which makes him a very debatable choice. At least he beat all those champions at some point, which is to his credit, and I’m pretty sure if I ever finish my rally drivers’ model, he’ll definitely be above average, but I’m not sure he’ll be so far above average to avoid ultimate rejection.
Märtin would maybe be a more obvious selection if he had been a successful career compiler, but he retired in 2005 (a season when Grönholm had destroyed him, by the way) after his co-driver Michael Park was killed in a crash. He never raced at the WRC level again, but occasionally entered and won minor events. And after his retirement in 2005, he was replaced by Davide Rigon. (No, not really.)
Verdict: Keep. I see no evidence that Märtin should be an immediate cut yet, and there probably won’t be many drivers with as many WRC wins as he has that I will reject (but I kind of think Kris Meeke will be one of them). He was at least halfway competitive with the championship contenders even if he wasn’t one himself and the fact that he competed in what was probably the WRC’s most competitive era helps, but his short career will probably make him a bubble driver right to the end, and I probably won’t make up my mind on this until/unless I complete my rally drivers’ model.

